Harsh Critiques

by | May 3, 2023 | Author | 2 comments

Hi, this is Janice Seagraves.

Before we start, I want to put this *disclaimer* out there. Please keep in mind that critiquers and critique groups are committing their time and effort for free. And it does help your work become more readable.

Are you afraid to join a critique group because of what they might say about your work? Or are you gun-shy because of a harsh critique?

Would it help you to know that I’ve gotten some harsh critiques in the past?

Years ago, I received one that began with… “This is why I hate romance.”

That critique… totally… destroyed me.

I was a wreck. I couldn’t write for weeks. It made me wonder if I was even cut out to be an author. But… I had to develop that all-important thick skin.  And the sad part was… I thought I had.

*sigh*

And…more recently I got another harsh critique.

I had to go off and pout for a couple of days before I could even look at that critique again.

When I did, I realized…my critique partner was correct. She gave it to me straight and didn’t pull any punches.

But, hey, there is always room for improvement.

Right?

Sometimes a manuscript will need a lot of work.

Here are some things to keep in mind when writing.

Remember to commit the emotion to the page. Most popular books today, tug at the heartstrings. They deliver the feels.

In every scene, try to incorporate the four senses: what they hear, what they see, and what they smell to really put your reader right there with your characters.

Now for the head hopping. Just remember to keep it to one scene, one POV. It’s as simple as that.

Easy peasy.

There are some wonderful tutorials on YouTube that can help. Critiques are the best way, but just reading in the genre that you’re writing in will greatly improve your skills, too.

Just keeping writing. Don’t ever stop.

Alien Collision: Alien Collision: Chronicles of Arcon – Kindle edition by Seagraves, Janice. Literature & Fiction Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.

2 Comments

  1. Janice Seagraves

    Thank you for posting my article. It was fun writing it. 🙂

    Janice Seagraves~

    Reply
  2. Cassie Exline

    Janice, good advice. The critique group I joined was a big help.

    As a newbie (back in the olden days of 2004), I read the comments, which were usually “great story or good story, like the characters, but…” Then I stopped reading until I was ready for the truth. Keep in mind, not everybody is on the same wavelength as the author or where his or her story is going.

    The advice I received from a seasoned writer was “the story is yours, use what you want, but keep in mind whether you want to sell it or not.”

    Sometimes the edits help spark the imagination and strengthen the story. My rewrites have always been stronger than when I started.

    Sold my first story in 2005. I listened and learned. Of course, it hurts, but I’d never trust any critique that only patted me on the back.

    Don’t give up. Writers write.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What Authors Say About ReadersMagnet

Archives

Google Review

Skip to content